KUTUZOV VERSUS NAPOLEON
AT BORODINO
John Sloan
This page displays photos taken on the battlefield at Borodino, Russia,
where the Russian army under Marshal Kutuzov fought the French and Allied army
of Napoleon in 1812, as well as related photos from several military museums
and photos of current Russian Napoleonic society reenactors. Attached are
tables showing the chronology of the campaign and of the battle as well as a
text narrative of the campaign based on Clausewitz. We have added a review of
the book, Borodino, by Alexander
Mikaberidze.
The Xenophon Group International conducts tours to the battlefield and museums
as well as to other historical and contemporary military locations in Russia
and Ukraine, including the Hermitage and Artillery Museum in St. Petersburg and
the museum of Soviet aircraft at Monino and museum of armored forces at
Kubinka. For information on future tours please contact Xenophon. The page was
last edited on 25 March 2009. Return to the main page on
the 1812 campaign.
Borodino is a village 124 km west of Moscow. On August 26, 1812 it was the
scene of the most decisive battle of the 1812 War with Napoleon. It was here
that the Russian commander-in-chief, Field Marshal Prince Michael Kutuzov,
following the surrender of Smolensk to the French forces took a decision to
stage a decisive battle against the Napoleonic army. The outcome of the battle
was favorable for the Russian army. Russian troops displayed outstanding
gallantry. Russia's army corps commanding generals included such outstanding
military commanders as Prince Bagration, Marshal Barclay de Tolly, M.
Miloradovich, B. Dokhtarov, M. Platov and others. The Russian army had 104,000
men and 627 guns. The French had 124,000 men and 587 guns. The casualties in
the Napoleon's army ran as high as over 50,000 dead and wounded (28,000
killed), the Russian casualty figures stood at 44,000. The Battle of Borodino
heralded a crisis in Napoleon's strategy of the General Battle. Napoleon failed
in this attempt to totally destroy the Russian army, make Russia surrender, and
dictate her peace terms. His forces suffered grave losses while the Russian
spirit was enhanced. The battle signalled the beginning of the catastrophe that
engulfed the Grand Army. Please go to text for a
narrative of the campaign. At 1812 there is a
chronological table of major events of the campaign. At battle time line is a table showing the hour by hour
course of the battle.
In 1941 there was vicious fighting at Borodino between Soviet and German
troops. The Borodino field features numerous monuments dedicated to the Russian
men in combat as well as the monument to the fallen French soldiers. Today
Borodino is an open-air museum spanning the territory of 110 sq kms. The tour
of this museum usually starts from the huge poplar that was planted in front of
the museum building in 1839 when the ashes of P. I. Bagration were buried in
the place of the former Raevsky's battery. Then the tourists would go up to
Gorki village where Marshal Mikhail Kutuzov's command post was located. From
the hill with the monument to the glorious Russian field marshal on its top,
one can observe most of the battlefield, as well as the location of the main
operations - the Shevardino redoubt, the Semenovski fleches, and the Ravesky
battery. To learn more about our activities and view other locations in Russia,
please return to the Xenophon Group main page
please go here. Go to reenactment to see photos of the Borodino reenactment
of 1999.
Maps of Borodino Battlefield
We are in process of making new maps
of the battle and the entire 1812 campaign. Here is a map of the opening days
of the campaign.
Selected photographs
Special exhibition on Marshal Kutuzov and leaders.
There is a special exhibition of artifacts related to Kutuzov and the 1812
campaign in the huge Museum of Artillery, Engineers and Signal Troops in St
Petersburg and there are more paintings in the Hero's gallery in the Hermitage.
We have photos taken during visits from 1992 to 2005.
Marshal Kutuzov The commander of the Russian combined
armies at Borodino. This portrait hangs in the 1812 heros gallery in the Winter
Palace, (Hermitage Museum) in St Petersburg.
Desk This field desk used by Kutuzov is in the
Museum of Artillery, Engineer, and Signal troops in St. Petersburg in a special
section devoted to Kutuzov.
Bed Kutuzov's field bed is also located in the
special section of the Artillery Museum
KutuzovA B/W drawing of the marshal in the Xenophon collection.
Portrait of Kutuzov in the Artillery Museum.
Uniforms in the Kutuzov Room.
Pistols and carbines in display cases.
Swords and trumpets on display.
Uniforms from 1812 era.
More uniforms and swords in the Artillery Museum.
Furniture formerly displayed in the special Kutuzov
museum in Germany.
Additional furniture in the special exhibition.
Portrait of Barclay de Tolly in the Artillery
museum.
Barclay de Tolly He was the commander of one of the Russian armies at
Borodino. This portrait is next to that of Kutuzov in the Hermitage.
Bust of general Barclay de Tolly at the
museum on the Borodino battlefield
Bagration He commanded the other Russian field army
at Borodino. He was killed in battle, hence his portrait is not in the Hero's
hall. This bust is located at the small museum on the Borodino Battlefield.
Painting of 1812 in Artillery Museum.
Painting of the 1812 campaign in the Artillery
museum
Cavalry in battle of Borodino.
Artillery and cavalry engaged at Borodino.
Painting of 1812 in Artillery Museum.
Burning village during 1812 campaign.
Picture display on wall of Artillery Museum.
Diorama of the battle made with military miniatures.
Napoleonic era cannon in Artillery museum.
Model in Artillery Museum of memorial to Kutuzov in
Germany.
Model of statue of Kutuzov.
Arch Triumphal arch in Moscow near the Panorama museum
Views of the Borodino Battlefield and of the painted scene in the Borodino
Panorama Museum in Moscow.
View from Gorki Kutuzov's field headquarters
during the battle was on this small hill to the rear of the right center of the
Russian battle line. The most critical part of the battle took place in the far
distance on the left side of this photograph.
The view from the mound at Gorki looking
more in the direction of Borodino village and the bridge between. Of course
these houses were not here during the battle.
Some military historians are visiting the
Borodino battlefield and walking to the location of Kutuzov's position at
Gorki.
A rainy day for our third visit to the Borodino
battlefield - here entering the sector where the French deployed.
View of the French positions around the captured
Sheverdino field fortification. Napoleon established his headquarters in this
area.
Monument to the French (Allied) army located near
where Napoleon sat during the battle, in front of the Sheverdino field
fortification.
We are driving on the access road into the area
where the French (and allied) forces deployed prior to the battle.
The area of the French army deployment now has many
trees.
View from the French monument located where
Napoleon sat during the battle, In the distance is the monastery built near the
rear of the three Bagration fleches. The trees were not there during the
battle. One can get an idea, however, of the distances involved and the very
gentle slopes involved.
View from the French monument located where
Napoleon sat during the battle, In the distance is the monastery built near the
rear of the three Bagration fleches. The trees were not there during the
battle. One can get an idea, however, of the distances involved and the very
gentle slopes involved. Dense undergrowth has now
filled much of the battlefield which was more open during the battle. This area
is where the French forces deployed for battle.
Panorama 1 This is one section of the magnificent 360
degree panorama of the battlefield housed in a special museum in Moscow. The
perspective is of a person standing in the center of the Russian line at
Semenovski village about 12:30 PM at the height of the French assault. They
have taken the fletches and have brought the Imperial Guard Foot Artillery
forward to nearly point blank range. The Saxon cavalry is attacking to the
right of the village and being met by Russian cavalry. In this view we are
looking to the left front with the captured fletches in far background.
Panorama 2 Another section of the huge painting. This
view is directly to the rear. Note the aid station in tents. The wounded
Bragration is in the two wheel cart.
Panorama 3 Another view of the battlefield as depicted
in the panorama. The view is to the right with Russian cavalry
counter-attacking
Panorama 4 Another view of the battlefield in this
marvelous panorama. The view to the right slightly rear with more Russian
cavalry approaching.
Panorama 5 It was not possible to photograph every
part of this huge painting, but this scene shows yet another aspect of the
bloody battlefield. Here the Russian cavalry is engaging the Saxons. The
Rayevski redoubt is encased in smoke in the distance.
Monument memorial to Barclay de Tolly with WWII pillbox
in front
Another view of the memorial itself.
The monument to Prince Bagration near the Rayevsky
redoubt - note the WWII pill box to the left of the tree
Kolotchka stream This view shows the stream just
south of the bridge on the country road near the Borodino village. During the
battle Eugene captured the bridge initially from Russian jagers but was driven
back. The French then had to build several pontoon bridges across this stream.
The main Russian positions were along the ridge to the left in the distance in
this view.
The Kolotchka stream from the Old Smolensk Road as
it crosses on a newer bridge. The Russians managed to burn the old bridge
during the battle.
Stream Another view of part of the Kolotchka stream
close to the bridge at Borodino.
Dense undergrowth has now filled much of the
battlefield which was more open during the battle. This area is near the
Kolotchka stream.
Rayevski redoubt Also called the Rayevski battery
after the Russian general who supervised its construction and defense. This
position on the military crest was the only significant fortification in the
Russian line. It was an effective emplacement for artillery from which the
Russians managed to repel repeated French attacks on the most critical right
center section of their front. It was finally taken, forcing the Russians to
withdraw. Note the entrenchments from World War II in the forground.
A baloon excursion is being offered in the field in
front of the Rayevski redoubt -seen on the ridge to the left. One can see that
the slope up which the French attacked is not very steep. The Russian positions
extended past the woods in the far distance.
FletcheThe only other field works of any importance
were three open, angle shaped fletches on the left side of the Russian line.
This shows the interior of one of them. They were taken by the French after
several assaults during the morning.
The Alexander Tuchkov Savior Monastery built by his
wife in memory of General Tuchkov IV, whose body was never found after he died
on the battlefield. He disappeared while leading a counter attack of the
Revelskii Infantry Regiment near this spot by the rearmost of the three
fleches. One of his brothers also was killed in this battle and another was
wounded at Smolensk. Margarita Mikhilovna Tuchkova spent her remainding life
memoralizing her lost husband. First she built The Church of the Savior as the
first monument constructed on the battlefield. The church was later expanded
into the Borodino Savior Monastery (convent) in 1838 of which Margarita was the
first mother superior. The buildings were damaged during the battle here in WW
II and restored in 1962. It is now an active monastery.
The General Alexander Tuchkov and Borodino Savior
Monastery.
The monastery built on the Borodino battlefield.
Touring group of military historians are checking it out. Note the end of one
of the fleches at the right.
The forward face of the fleche - these were
surprisingly large positions, to enable the deployment of cannon and infantry
support.
Ditch This shows the ditch just outside one wall of
one of the three fletches. They were simple earthen ramparts thrown up from the
dirt out of the ditch, with embrasures for cannon.
The view over the top of the rampart, with ditch
immediately below, toward the south-west from where the French were attacking
this fleche and also through the woods toward the Russian left flank.
Fletche and monastery Another view of one wall of a
fletche. In the background is one church built after the battle as part of a
monastery constructed on the site.
Buildings of the monastery on the Borodino
battlefield.
Borodino fletche The earthen rampart of one fletche.
View of the rear fletch from in front across the
ditch to the rampart. A monastery building is behind it.
When standing in the ditch (even though it is no
longer as deep) one finds the rampart to be much higher.
FieldA general view of the battlefield looking toward
the French lines and Borodino church. Eugene mounted his assault in this area.
Note the World War II emplacement. This same field was part of the critical
defense line of Moscow during 1941.
WWII emplacement Another view of the batttlefield focused on the positions
built in 1941 along the same line the Russians occupied in 1812.
A WWII pillbox in front of the Rayevski redoubt.
WW II trench Another of the modern entrenchments so
prominent on the 1812 battlefield
Another WWII trench
Some WWII trenches and a pillbox on the Borodino
battlefield
Another reminder of the Soviet Army defensive
positions dug during WWII across the Borodino battlefield.
World War II trench and dugouts on the Borodino
battlefield.
Friends visiting the Borodino Military Historical
Museum- Preserve on a rainy day. The museum-preserve was created in 1839 to
include the Rayevsky redoubt, Prince Bagration's grave and the main part of the
battlefield. In 1859 General Tochkov's widow, Margarita's house became a
museum. A new museum was built for the centenial in 1912 along with many of the
monuments . Its contents were evacuated during WWII but the original building
was destroyed. The present building was designed by V. Voyeikov and contains a
very extensive collection of original items, including those belonging to
Napoleon and Alexander, Kutuzov, Barclay de Tolly, Bagration and others.
A large map of the battlefield on a wall in the
Borodino museum
A diorama inside the Borodino museum depicting the
Russians defending a fletch with infantry regiments in hand to hand combat.
Cannon This display of captured French cannon is at
the entrance to the fine museum on the Borodino battlefield.
Cannon - another view of the captured cannon at the
Borodino battlefield museum. Many more such cannon are on display in the
Kremlin in Moscow and at the Artillery Museum in St. Petersburg.
Painting of the battle in the Borodino museum at the
battlefield
This partial circle diorama of Borodino battle is at
the museum on the battlefield.
A table top diorama of the Borodino battle. The
view is from the north with Borodino village in the lower center, and Gorki
(Kutuzov position) to the left and above the Kolotcha streem that flows between
them from right to left. The Rayevski redoubt (battery) is directly above
Borodino across the stream. The fletches are right of it. Shevardino
(Napoleon's position) is on the right border of the photograph near the top.
Another view of part of the same diorama.
Table top diorama with small model soldiers in the
Borodino museum - View is from behind Shevardino - the mound with French flag
is at center of photo. The French old guard is formed around Napoleon. The
reserve cavalry corps are to the right. Directly ahead are the fletches. On the
far right beyond the woods is Utitsa and the Polish wing attacking. The white
church in Borodino is on the far left edge of the photo with the white New
Smolensk Road along the edge.
In this view of the diorama we are almost over the
French headquarters and Napoleon, shown by the French flag just to the right of
center part way up the photo. The French army is deployed with Old Guard around
Napoleon and masses of French and allied reserve cavalry to the right lower
part. Borodino church is at the left edge just across the New Smolensk Road.
Gorki is above it. The Rayevski battery appears to the right of Borodino and
across the stream with masses of Russian infantry on both sides. The Bagration
fletches can be seen well in this view directly above the French flag with a
path leading between them.
In this view of the diorama we are behind the
Russian right flank. Gorki is slightly right of center on the New Smolensk
Road. The church of Borodino is right across the stream. The French (allied)
forces are at the top of the photo with Eugene's Italians on the right and the
mass of cavalry reserve at the far top of the table. The French flag at
Napoleon's headquarters can't be seen in this view.
In this view of the table top diorama we are flying
over Prince Eugene's Italian Corps a bit noth-west of Borodino village. The
French troops are deployed to his right and in the distance we see the French
flag over Napoleon's location at the Sheverdino redoubt. Directly above
Borodino is Gorki, where Kutuzov remained. The Rayevski battery (redoubt) is
easily seen. Two of the Bagration flectches are visible. The remainder of the
Russian line is out of the photo. At this time the French are deployed but not
yet attacking.
This view is from the south, over the Old Smolensk
Road and some of the Polish corps is at the bottom edge of the photo. The three
Bagration fletches are in the center just above the woods. Semyenovski ruined
village is close above them. Note the stream in a ravine that the French
cavalry had to pass through. The Rayevski redoubt is clearly seen and beyond it
the church in Borodino village. The diorama table does not include much of the
Russian far right and far left positions.
Here we are flying over the battlefield - the church
in Borodino is directly ahead - Gorki stands out above and to the right - The
Rayevski redoubt is in the center with masses of Russian infantry on both sides
and behind it. To the right is Semyenovski and then the Bagration fletches
behind the Kanenka stream. This view shows the steep ravine in front of the
Russian position at Semyanovskoye.
The table top diorama
A copy of the Verischagin painting of Napoleon seated
during the Borodino battle.
Other Paintings and displays in the Artillery Museum and Hermitage.
Diorama depicting the final French assault (by
cavalry) on the Great (Rayevski) redoubt during Borodino battle. Note the
Borodino church in background. This diorama is in the Artillery Museum.
Painting of Kutuzov conference at Fili prior to
abandonment of Moscow
Painting Grand Prince, General Constantine Pavlovich,
commander of Russian Imperial Guard division at Austerlitz and Borodino. -
painting on the 1812 Hall of the Winter Palace.
Portrait of equestrian Emperor of Austria Franz
Ferdinand, in the 1812 hall of the Winter Palace. Of course he was not at
Borodino and in fact his Austrian army was then allied with Napoleon and
fighting Russians far to the west, but, since he was an ally for the final
campaigns to defeat Napoleon it was considered politic to include him here.
Equestrian portrait of Prussian King Frederick William,
in the 1812 Hall of the Winter Palace. He is here under the same circumstances
and for same reason as Franz Ferdinand.
Portraits - A part of one wall of the 1812 Hall showing
portraits of Russian general officers who fought at Borodino. - in the Winter
Palace.
Portraits of some other generals along one of the
walls of the 1812 hall. All the surviving generals are shown and there are
spaces for those who died.
One wall in the 1812 Heros gallery with paintings
of Russian general officers who fought in 1812 campaign.
New photo from 2005 - Field Marshal, Prince, Kutuzov,
commander of Russian combined armies at Borodino, portrait in the 1812 Hall of
the Winter Palace.
New photo from 2005 - General Barclay de Tolly,
commander of Russian First West Army at Borodino - portrait in the 1812 Hall of
the Hermitage.
The Duke of Wellington, commander of British forces at
Waterloo, portrait in the 1812 Hall of the Hermitage. Of course he also was no
where near Borodino, but at least he was holding many French troops in Spain.
Detail portrait of one of the hussar generals on wall
in 1812 room of Hermitage.
Large painting in the Hermitage Hall of 1812 depicting
moment at Borodino battle when General Prince Bragration was mortally wounded.
He was the hero of the battle, but since he was dead, his formal portrait does
not appear in the hall. Also, none of the other generals who had died have
their portraits made by English artist, Dawes after the battle are there.
Another Painting depicting the mortal wounding of
General Prince Bragation during Borodino battle. This one is in the Artillery
Museum
The portrait of Alexander I occupies one end wall of
the 1812 memorial hall in the Winter Palace.
Painting depicting Russian army during
1812campaign. This hangs in the Artillery museum
Russian regimental standard from 1812 campaign. It
is in the Artillery Museum
Display case containing bust of Napoleon and
various weapons and uniforms. It is also in the special Kutuzov room of the
Artillery museum
New photo from 2005 - Display of various furniture
belonging to Marshal Kutusov during the 1812 campaign - part of large special
exhibition in honor of Kutusov.
Another view of the display of various furniture
belonging to Marshal Kutusov during the 1812 campaign - part of large special
exhibition in honor of Kutusov.
New photo from 2005 - Portrait of General Barclay
de Tolly, Russian minister of war and commander of the First West Army during
the1812 campaign. It is in the Artillery museum
Photos of Russian Napoleonic era reenactors.
Russian Dragoon A photo of Vadim Grushinin in
the uniform of the Moscow Dragoon Regiment. He is a prominent Napoleonic era
reenactor who also creates 54 mm model soldiers.
Dragoons Some of the Moscow Dragoons forming for drill.
Pavlov Grenadier Regiment in winter overcoats. This famous regiment was the
only one to retain their miter caps right up until 1917.
Hussars Reenactors in St. Petersburg wearing hussar
uniforms. The major reenactment takes place each year on the first Sunday of
September on the battlefield.
French infantry A unit of young Russian reenactors
dressed as French Infantry.
French infantry 2 Another view of Russian reenactors
practicing their hobby.
Reenactors Another unit of French infantry depicted
by Russians in St. Petersburg.
Photos from the reenactment in Sept 1999.
Please check out
Napoleon for our section on Napoleon and the French Army. We have many
illustrations of the uniforms of the Russian army of Alexander I and will post
them to this web page as soon as possible. Go to top.
Please send comments and questions including opportunities to join in
future tours to the locations included here to
Xenophon or sign our
guestbook. For more
material on the history of Russia and Ukraine please go to
Xenophon home page.