logo
 

NUMBERS IN HISTORY

 
 

HANS DELBRUCK

 
 

Subtitle: How the Greeks Defeated the Persians - The Romans Conquered the World - The Teutons Overthrew the Roman Empire - and William The Norman Took Possession of England

 {short description of image}

Two Lectures delivered before the University of London on October 6 and 7, 1913. London. Univ. of London Press, Hodder and Stoughton 1913. This is a link to the text of the published book in printed format.

 
 

Delbruck in his lecture to English students focuses on his methods in analyzing military events described in contemporary texts such as Herodotus for the battle of Marathon and Polybius and others for Roman battles such as Cannae. Considering the interests of his audience, he chose also to include as examples; the Swiss-Burgundian Wars, and the Norman conquest of Anglo-Saxon England. He was a pioneer in the re-evaluating the numbers given for the armies in these battles and campaigns. He compared those numbers with the numbers that are well known for modern battles and concluded that Herodotus, Caesar and most others greatly exaggerated the numbers. He considered known facts such as the size of battlefields, available transportation, access roads, food and other logistics factors. His conclusions greatly disturbed many of this contemporaries, but eventually his methods were admitted.
But in the 100 years since Delbruck studied the available sources the study of ancient and medieval warfare, using his own methods, but using a greatly expanded number of sources, plus application of modern methods such as sociology and archeology, had changed the accepted conclusions about the same battles.

The other major development in the study of military history that Delbruck championed was the application of Clausewitz's dictum that war is a continuation of politics. That idea was not only accepted but enshrined. But was not widely applied in the history texts. Delbruck's analysis of the causes, results and strategies in wars was based on the tight link between politics and warfare.
He also developed Clausewitz's theory about 'limited and unlimited' warfare. This, he defined as two different strategies - 'war of exhaustion' and 'war of destruction' translated into English as 'war of attrition' and 'war of annihilation.

 
 

In all three of Delbruck's examples modern scholarship recognizes the question of actual numbers of participants in battles and the significance of the political-military relationship, but has found much else that alters descriptions of his examples.

 

Return to Xenophon. Return to Ruscity. Return to Rushistory. Return to Ukraine.